Our children do not need to be made Meaning Factcheck Usage

Our children do not need to be made to feel bad… it’s a game-changing idea, right? This quote from Marshall Rosenberg flips traditional parenting on its head, arguing that shame is not a required ingredient for raising good humans. Let’s break down why this approach is so powerful and how you can actually use it.

Share Image Quote:

Table of Contents

• Meaning
• Explanation
• Origin & Factcheck
• Context
• Usage Examples
• Common Questions

Meaning

At its core, this is about decoupling discipline from shame. It means that a child’s moral development doesn’t have to be built on a foundation of guilt, blame, or feeling fundamentally “bad.”

Explanation

Okay, so here’s the real-world magic of this. For years, the default parenting mode was, “You should feel bad about what you did.” The thinking was that this bad feeling would teach the lesson. But what Rosenberg figured out—and what I’ve seen over and over—is that when a child feels bad about *themselves*, they aren’t learning the lesson. They’re just learning to feel shame. Their brain goes into fight, flight, or freeze. The learning part shuts down.

The alternative? Connect to the need behind the action. If a kid hits their sibling, the old way is, “Go to your room! You’re a bad boy!” The NVC way is, “I see you’re really angry. It’s not okay to hit because it hurts people. Let’s figure out a way to express that anger that doesn’t hurt anyone.” You’re addressing the exact same behavior, but you’re guiding them toward a better solution without making them feel like a terrible person. It preserves their dignity. And that’s where real, lasting learning happens.

Quote Summary

Context	Attributes
Original Language	English (3669)
Category	Wisdom (385)
Topics	growth (413), learning (190), morality (5)
Literary Style	reflective (255)
Emotion / Mood	gentle (183), provocative (175)
Overall Quote Score	76 (131)

Origin & Factcheck

This quote comes straight from Marshall B. Rosenberg’s 2005 book, Raising Children Compassionately: Parenting the Nonviolent Communication Way. It’s a core tenet of his Nonviolent Communication (NVC) framework. You sometimes see the sentiment echoed in positive parenting circles, but this specific phrasing is Rosenberg’s.

Attribution Summary

Context	Attributes
Author	Marshall B. Rosenberg (190)
Source Type	Book (4032)
Source/Book Name	Raising Children Compassionately: Parenting the Nonviolent Communication Way (135)
Origin Timeperiod	Contemporary (1615)
Original Language	English (3669)
Authenticity	Verified (4032)

Where is this quotation located?

Quotation	Our children do not need to be made to feel bad to learn what is good
Book Details	Publication Year/Date: 2004; ISBN/Unique Identifier: 9781892005140; Last edition: PuddleDancer Press, 1st Edition, 48 pages.
Where is it?	Chapter: Encouraging Growth, Approximate page from 2005 edition

Context

In the book, this isn’t just a throwaway line. It’s the central argument against what he calls “dominator” culture in parenting—the idea that we have to force our will on children. He positions this compassionate approach as the foundation for teaching cooperation and empathy, not through fear, but through mutual understanding and respect.

Usage Examples

This is where the rubber meets the road. It’s one thing to understand the theory, another to use it. Here’s how it looks for different folks:

• For a frustrated parent: Instead of “How many times have I told you not to leave your toys there? You never listen!” you try, “I feel frustrated when I see toys in the hallway because I’m worried someone will trip. Would you be willing to put them back in your room?” You’re stating your feeling and the need for safety, not attacking their character.
• For a teacher in a classroom: Instead of “That was a selfish thing to do,” to a student who took all the crayons, you might say, “I see you’re excited to use the crayons. Other students need them too. How can we make sure everyone gets a turn?” You’re guiding them toward a social solution.
• For a coach mentoring a team: After a loss, instead of “You should be ashamed of that performance,” a coach could say, “I know we’re all feeling disappointed we didn’t win. Let’s look at what we can learn from this game to be stronger next time.” This builds resilience instead of shame.

To whom it appeals?

Context	Attributes
Theme	Wisdom (1754)
Audiences	coaches (1277), educators (295), mentors (105), parents (430), therapists (555)
Usage Context/Scenario	child development talks (4), classroom discussions (12), ethical education (2), motivational workshops (58), positive parenting blogs (1)

Share This Quote Image & Motivate

Common Questions

Question: But if I don’t make them feel bad, how will they learn it’s wrong? Isn’t guilt a necessary part of conscience?

Answer: This is the biggest hurdle. The goal isn’t to remove all consequences or feelings of remorse. Healthy remorse—”I feel bad that my action hurt someone”—is different from toxic shame—”I *am* a bad person.” Rosenberg’s method focuses on fostering the former by connecting the child’s action to its impact on others’ feelings, which builds genuine empathy, not just a fear of punishment.

Question: This sounds like permissive parenting. Are you saying we should never say “no”?

Answer: Not at all! This is actually *more* demanding than authoritarian parenting. You still enforce clear boundaries. The difference is *how* you enforce them. You hold the line with empathy. “I won’t let you hit. I can see you’re furious, and we need to find another way for you to show that.” The limit is firm, but the child’s humanity is respected.

Question: Is this only for young children?

Answer: Absolutely not. The principle applies to teenagers, employees, and even in our own self-talk. The idea that people don’t need to feel bad about themselves to learn and grow is a universal human truth. It’s about effective communication at any age.