We cannot numb the dark without dimming the Meaning Factcheck Usage

You know, that line from Brene Brown, “We cannot numb the dark without dimming the light,” has stuck with me for years. It’s a simple but brutal truth about how our emotional defenses work. We think we’re just blocking out the bad stuff, but the mechanism is far less selective than that.

Share Image Quote:

Table of Contents

• Meaning
• Explanation
• Origin & Factcheck
• Context
• Usage Examples
• FAQ

Meaning

At its core, this quote means you can’t selectively shut down painful emotions without also reducing your capacity for joy and connection. The very system you use to protect yourself is an all-or-nothing deal.

Explanation

Think of your emotional capacity like a single volume dial for your entire being. When you turn down the volume on the difficult feelings—the shame, the grief, the vulnerability—you’re not just turning down one channel. You’re turning down the entire system. So that same numbing that helps you ignore anxiety also makes your triumphs feel flatter, your laughter a little quieter, your love less intense. It’s a package deal. And that last part, “avoidance does not discriminate,” is the kicker. It’s not a smart, surgical tool. It’s a blunt instrument.

Quote Summary

Context	Attributes
Original Language	English (3669)
Category	Wisdom (385)
Topics	avoidance (6), emotion general (105), numbing (7)
Literary Style	clinical (8), metaphoric (105)
Emotion / Mood	calm (491), sobering (17)
Overall Quote Score	71 (53)

Origin & Factcheck

This wisdom comes straight from Brené Brown’s 2004 book, Women & Shame: Reaching Out, Speaking Truths, which was published in the United States. It’s a foundational concept in her early work on shame and vulnerability, long before her famous TED Talk. You sometimes see it floating around unattributed, but it’s unequivocally hers.

Attribution Summary

Context	Attributes
Author	Brene Brown (257)
Source Type	Book (4032)
Source/Book Name	Women & Shame: Reaching Out, Speaking Truths (39)
Origin Timeperiod	21st Century (1892)
Original Language	English (3669)
Authenticity	Verified (4032)

Where is this quotation located?

Quotation	We cannot numb the dark without dimming the light; avoidance does not discriminate
Book Details	Publication Year: 2004; (other edition details unknown)
Where is it?	Approximate page from 2004 Hazelden edition, Section: Numbing and Avoidance

Context

Brown was deep in her research on women and shame when she penned this. She observed that to avoid the intense pain of shame, people often employ numbing strategies—anything from perfectionism to substance use. This quote was her powerful, concise way of explaining the devastating, hidden cost of that choice.

Usage Examples

I use this all the time in my work. It’s perfect for:

• Coaching a high-achiever: I’ll say, “Look, I see you using work to numb the fear of failure. But notice how you also feel disconnected from your family’s joy? That’s the light dimming.”
• Advising a team leader: “When you create a culture where people can’t show uncertainty or sadness, you’re also, unintentionally, creating a place where they can’t show wild enthusiasm or creative passion. You get a polite, but muted, team.”
• Personal reflection: Honestly, I ask myself, “Am I scrolling to numb out? Because if I am, I’m also opting out of truly feeling the good stuff waiting for me just off-screen.”

To whom it appeals?

Context	Attributes
Theme	Principle (838)
Audiences	coaches (1277), leaders (2620), parents (430), students (3112), therapists (555)
Usage Context/Scenario	addiction education (1), clinician training (1), parent nights (8), SEL lessons (2), self-help chapters (2), team wellbeing (4)

Share This Quote Image & Motivate

FAQ

Question: So, are we just supposed to feel all the bad stuff all the time?

Answer: Great question. No, not at all. The goal isn’t to be a raw nerve. It’s about developing resilience—the ability to feel the emotion, process it, and move through it—rather than trying to preemptively shut it down. Resilience is selective; numbing is not.

Question: What does “numbing” actually look like in real life?

Answer: It’s any behavior we use to escape or avoid discomfort. The big ones are perfectionism, substance use, binge-watching, emotional eating, cynicism, even staying “crazy busy” all the time. It’s anything that puts a buffer between you and a feeling you don’t want to have.

Question: Is this quote only relevant for people dealing with trauma?

Answer: Not at all. This is a universal human experience. Ever had a tough day at work and then been too tired to really engage with your kids? That’s a micro-version of it. We all do it. The quote just makes us aware of the hidden trade-off.